Issue Bug Rejected

#103153Wrong behaviour of $storage->hasFile($identifier)

Tee Ohh 02/19/24, 16:34 updated 02/20/24, 14:30

Description

System environment

I have a docker container with Ubuntu on a Windows 10 maschine for development. The file system is shared between Ubuntu and Windows.

TYPO3 setup

The local fileadmin storage has an enabled “Uses case sensitive identifiers” checkbox.
I can create case sensitive file names in the TYPO3 backend without problems.
If I use the function $storage->hasFile($identifier) from the default storage to check if a file is available and the identifier is in lower case (example.txt), but the file name is upper case (Example.text), the function returns true. This is wrong. In the same time an additional sys_file record is created with a lower case identifier and a lower case file name. That is also wrong.

Steps to reproduce

1. Create a file in the file list with the name “Example.text”.
2. Check the sys_file record: Identifier: “/Example.txt”, name: “Example.txt“
3. Execute the following script:

<?php
declare(strict_types = 1);

namespace Vendor\MyExtension;

use TYPO3\CMS\Core\Resource\StorageRepository;

class ExampleClass
{
    protected StorageRepository $storageRepository;

    /**
     * Constructor
     * 
     * @param StorageRepository $storageRepository
     */
    public function __construct(StorageRepository $storageRepository) {
        $this->storageRepository = $storageRepository;
    }

    /**
     * Example function
     */
    public function exampleFunction()
    {
        // Get storage
        $storage = $this->storageRepository->getDefaultStorage();

        // Check file
        $result = $storage->hasFile('example.txt');

        // Debug
        debug($result, 'example.txt is available?');
    }
}

4. The debug result is true and a second sys_file record exists: Identifier: “/example.txt”, name: “example.txt”. But in the file system only Example.txt exists.

The function should return false and also creating not a second sys_file record with wrong data.

Reviews 0

No change resolves or names this issue in its commit message, and no comment links one.

History 3

  1. Andreas Kienast commented and changed status New Needs Feedback 02/20/24, 09:35

    Can you please explain your system? Do you use WSL? Who is the host of the filesystem? If Windows is the host, I think there’s not much we can do here as the underlying NTFS is case-insensitive.

  2. Tee Ohh commented 02/20/24, 09:47

    I do NOT use a WSL based engine for Docker. Maybe the host of the file system is Windows. I don’t know it. Hopefully the docker-compose.yml file helps. I see in Windows Exploer all the files and folders starting from /var/www/html/.

    version: "3.7"
    
    services:
    
      redis:
        container_name: ${COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME}_redis
        image: ${REDIS_IMAGE:-redis:alpine}
        environment:
          - REDIS_REPLICATION_MODE=${REDIS_REPLICATION_MODE:-master}
        volumes:
          - redis:/var/lib/redis
        ports:
          - ${REDIS_PORT:-6219}:6379
        command: redis-server --requirepass ${REDIS_ROOT_PASSWORD:-********}
    
      db:
        container_name: ${COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME}_db
        image: ${DB_IMAGE:-mariadb:10.5}
        environment:
          - MYSQL_ROOT_PASSWORD=${MYSQL_ROOT_PASSWORD:-********}
        volumes:
          - db:/var/lib/mysql
        ports:
          - ${DB_PORT:-6019}:3306
        command:
          - --character-set-server=utf8mb4
          - --collation-server=utf8mb4_unicode_ci
          - --sql_mode=NO_ENGINE_SUBSTITUTION
    
      web:
        container_name: ${COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME}_web
        build:
          context: ${WEB_IMAGE:-https://git.********}
          args:
            TYPO3_WEB_DIR: ${TYPO3_WEB_DIR}
        depends_on:
          - db
          - redis
        environment:
          - VIRTUAL_HOST=${COMPOSE_PROJECT_HOST}
          - TYPO3_CONTEXT=${TYPO3_CONTEXT:-Development/local}
          - TYPO3_ADMIN_USER=${TYPO3_ADMIN_USER:-admin}
          - TYPO3_ADMIN_PASSWORD=${TYPO3_ADMIN_PASSWORD:-********}
    
          - DB_HOST=${COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME}_db
          - MYSQL_ROOT_PASSWORD=${MYSQL_ROOT_PASSWORD:-********}
          - DB_NAME=${DB_NAME:-typo3}
          - DB_USER=${DB_USER:-root}
    
          - USER_ID=${USER_ID:-1000}
    
          - COMPOSER_AUTH=${COMPOSER_AUTH}
        healthcheck:
          disable: true
        volumes:
          - ../:/var/www/html${FILE_SYSTEM_MODE:-:delegated}
    
    networks:
      default:
        name: webproxy
        external: true
    
    volumes:
      db:
        name: ${COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME}_db
      redis:
        name: ${COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME}_redis
  3. Benjamin Franzke commented and changed status Needs Feedback Rejected 02/20/24, 14:30

    Thanks for the docker-composer and the additional information.

    You are using a native Windows folder (case-insensitive) and mount that into docker. As docker has to relay all files to the host filesystem, that means the file system will also behave case-insensitive (although being masked as being something like ext2, it is not) and that means you must not configure “Uses case sensitive identifiers” in that case, since you are using a case-insensitive filesystem.

    Please change the configuration of your TYPO3 file storage or even better (I guess you copied this system from a linux server), write the files to a native WSL storage (not /mnt/c, but sth like /home/…) and run docker from WSL/with WSL engine.