Issue Bug Closed

#105703Premature end of script headers due to X-TYPO3-Cache-Tags

Daniel Siepmann 11/26/24, 13:03 updated 12/02/25, 14:31

Description

Steps to reproduce:

  1. Clean TYPO3 installation
  2. Apache
  3. Add a LOT of cache tags, e.g. tt_address list plugin with lots of records.
  4. Break the limit of apaches header sizes

Drupal had the same issue. More info is available at: https://github.com/docksal/docksal/issues/1110
They solved it by adding multiple headers splitting the list of tags: https://www.drupal.org/files/issues/2019-05-30/finish-response-subscriber—need-warning-error-when-headers-exceed-16k-2844620-20.patch

Our internal corresponding issue: “Aufgabe #11275 TYPO3 Upgrade 13 LTS” in order to more easily find a project where we can verify any fixes.

Reviews 2

History 2028

Show 3 earlier messages
  1. Martin Weymayer commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2024-12-04T06:07:48+00:00" > 12/04/24, 06:07 </span>

    Same problem with custom extension and images.

  2. Martin Weymayer commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2024-12-07T16:35:28+00:00" > 12/07/24, 16:35 </span>

    I could locate problem. It is causes in file sysext/core/Classes/Middleware/CacheDataCollectorAttribute.php line 57:

    $response = $response->withHeader('X-TYPO3-Cache-Tags', implode(',', $cacheTags));

    In my case the outpout is too big:
    [X-TYPO3-Cache-Tags] => Array
    (
    [0] => pages_1,pages_11,pages_12,pages_16,pages_17,pages_2,pages_20,pages_21,pages_22,pages_25,pages_3,pages_4,pages_5,pages_6,pages_7,pages_9,sys_file_1253,sys_file_1254,sys_file_1255,sys_file_1256,sys_file_1257,sys_file_1260,sys_file_1261,sys_file_1262,sys_file_1263,sys_file_1266,sys_file_1267,sys_file_1273,sys_file_1275,sys_file_1279,sys_file_1282,sys_file_1285,sys_file_1287,sys_file_1300,sys_file_1307,sys_file_1309,sys_file_1313,sys_file_1319,sys_file_26,sys_file_metadata_1253,sys_file_metadata_1254,sys_file_metadata_1255,sys_file_metadata_1256,sys_file_metadata_1257,sys_file_metadata_1260,sys_file_metadata_1261,sys_file_metadata_1262,sys_file_metadata_1264,sys_file_metadata_1265,sys_file_metadata_1266,sys_file_metadata_1274,sys_file_metadata_1275,sys_file_metadata_1280,sys_file_metadata_1284,sys_file_metadata_1285,sys_file_metadata_1286,sys_file_metadata_1299,sys_file_metadata_1307,sys_file_metadata_1311,sys_file_metadata_1314,sys_file_metadata_1319,sys_file_metadata_26,sys_file_reference_1040,sys_file_reference_1043,sys_file_reference_1068,sys_file_reference_896,sys_file_reference_898,sys_file_reference_902,sys_file_reference_906,sys_file_reference_910,sys_file_reference_912,sys_file_reference_913,sys_file_reference_914,sys_file_reference_915,sys_file_reference_916,sys_file_reference_917,sys_file_reference_918,sys_file_reference_919,sys_file_reference_922,sys_file_reference_923,sys_file_reference_926,sys_file_reference_928,sys_file_reference_931,sys_file_reference_935,tt_content_16,tt_content_17,tt_content_2,tt_content_21,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_1,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_10,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_11,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_12,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_13,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_14,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_15,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_16,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_17,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_18,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_19,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_2,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_20,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_21,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_22,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_23,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_24,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_25,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_26,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_3,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_4,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_5,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_6,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_7,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_8,tx_meineextension_domain_model_alphabet_9,tx_meineextension_domain_model_branche_10,tx_meineextension_domain_model_branche_11,tx_meineextension_domain_model_branche_12,tx_meineextension_domain_model_branche_13,tx_meineextension_domain_model_branche_5,tx_meineextension_domain_model_branche_6,tx_meineextension_domain_model_branche_7,tx_meineextension_domain_model_branche_8,tx_meineextension_domain_model_branche_9,tx_meineextension_domain_model_branche_pid_19,tx_meineextension_domain_model_kategorie_1,tx_meineextension_domain_model_kategorie_2,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_10,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_100,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_102,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_103,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_104,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_105,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_107,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_109,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_11,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_110,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_111,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_112,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_114,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_115,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_116,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_118,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_120,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_122,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_124,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_126,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_127,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_129,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_131,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_132,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_134,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_135,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_136,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_138,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_140,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_141,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_143,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_145,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_146,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_147,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_15,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_150,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_151,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_152,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_153,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_154,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_155,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_157,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_158,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_159,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_162,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_163,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_164,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_165,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_166,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_167,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_169,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_19,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_20,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_21,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_22,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_23,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_26,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_28,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_29,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_3,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_31,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_32,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_33,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_34,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_35,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_36,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_37,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_38,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_39,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_4,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_40,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_42,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_43,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_44,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_45,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_46,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_47,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_48,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_49,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_50,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_51,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_52,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_53,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_54,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_55,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_57,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_58,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_6,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_60,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_61,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_62,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_63,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_64,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_68,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_69,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_71,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_74,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_77,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_78,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_8,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_80,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_81,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_82,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_83,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_84,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_85,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_9,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_90,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_92,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_93,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_94,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_95,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_96,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_97,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_98,tx_meineextension_domain_model_mitglied_99
    )

    this break the limit of apaches header sizes.

  1. Arne Bracht commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2024-12-28T19:10:44+00:00" > 12/28/24, 19:10 </span>

    Not a solution, but you can deactivate the new Feature under “Feature Toggles” or direkt in settings.php

            'features' => [
                'frontend.cache.autoTagging' => false,
            ],
  2. Sascha Nowak commented and changed status Under Review Resolved done 0 % 100 % <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2025-04-08T18:45:08+00:00" > 04/08/25, 18:45 </span>

    Applied in changeset commit:0b9a91899301227c7a7fa348151f4e6fa309e7dc.

  3. Martin Weymayer commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2025-09-10T13:25:22+00:00" > 09/10/25, 13:25 </span>

    Problem NOT solved with latest update! :-( Error still occures in 13.4.18

  4. Garvin Hicking commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2025-09-10T16:13:48+00:00" > 09/10/25, 16:13 </span>

    @matin73 What is your header output now? It should be split at some point at least?

  5. Martin Weymayer commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2025-09-10T16:15:28+00:00" > 09/10/25, 16:15 </span>

    the problem is, that header output is still more than 8kb

  6. Garvin Hicking commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2025-09-10T16:23:23+00:00" > 09/10/25, 16:23 </span>

    Does it not get split at all? Or are the splits larger than your limit?

    Can you alter the code to use a lower limit?

  7. Martin Weymayer commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2025-09-23T06:46:57+00:00" > 09/23/25, 06:46 </span>

    I hav some imagegallery. so this can not be shorten!

  8. Martin Weymayer commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2025-09-23T07:17:13+00:00" > 09/23/25, 07:17 </span>

    Problem seems only in debug mode: here is output:
    [X-TYPO3-Cache-Tags] => Array
    (
    [0] => pageId_1 pages_1 pages_2 pages_3 sys_file_101 sys_file_102 sys_file_103 sys_file_104 sys_file_105 sys_file_106 sys_file_107 sys_file_108 sys_file_109 sys_file_11 sys_file_112 sys_file_113 sys_file_115 sys_file_117 sys_file_118 sys_file_124 sys_file_128 sys_file_13 sys_file_137 sys_file_14 sys_file_141 sys_file_146 sys_file_15 sys_file_155 sys_file_156 sys_file_157 sys_file_158 sys_file_159 sys_file_16 sys_file_160 sys_file_161 sys_file_162 sys_file_163 sys_file_164 sys_file_165 sys_file_166 sys_file_167 sys_file_168 sys_file_169 sys_file_170 sys_file_171 sys_file_173 sys_file_174 sys_file_175 sys_file_21 sys_file_25 sys_file_28 sys_file_30 sys_file_33 sys_file_37 sys_file_39 sys_file_40 sys_file_42 sys_file_43 sys_file_44 sys_file_45 sys_file_48 sys_file_49 sys_file_50 sys_file_51 sys_file_52 sys_file_53 sys_file_54 sys_file_55 sys_file_57 sys_file_58 sys_file_59 sys_file_60 sys_file_61 sys_file_62 sys_file_63 sys_file_64 sys_file_67 sys_file_68 sys_file_69 sys_file_71 sys_file_72 sys_file_78 sys_file_82 sys_file_84 sys_file_88 sys_file_89 sys_file_90 sys_file_91 sys_file_metadata_101 sys_file_metadata_102 sys_file_metadata_103 sys_file_metadata_104 sys_file_metadata_105 sys_file_metadata_106 sys_file_metadata_107 sys_file_metadata_108 sys_file_metadata_109 sys_file_metadata_11 sys_file_metadata_111 sys_file_metadata_113 sys_file_metadata_115 sys_file_metadata_116 sys_file_metadata_118 sys_file_metadata_124 sys_file_metadata_128 sys_file_metadata_13 sys_file_metadata_137 sys_file_metadata_14 sys_file_metadata_141 sys_file_metadata_146 sys_file_metadata_15 sys_file_metadata_155 sys_file_metadata_156 sys_file_metadata_157 sys_file_metadata_158 sys_file_metadata_159 sys_file_metadata_16 sys_file_metadata_160 sys_file_metadata_161 sys_file_metadata_162 sys_file_metadata_163 sys_file_metadata_164 sys_file_metadata_165 sys_file_metadata_166 sys_file_metadata_167 sys_file_metadata_168 sys_file_metadata_169 sys_file_metadata_170 sys_file_metadata_171 sys_file_metadata_173 sys_file_metadata_174 sys_file_metadata_175 sys_file_metadata_21 sys_file_metadata_24 sys_file_metadata_28 sys_file_metadata_30 sys_file_metadata_33 sys_file_metadata_37 sys_file_metadata_39 sys_file_metadata_40 sys_file_metadata_42 sys_file_metadata_43 sys_file_metadata_44 sys_file_metadata_45 sys_file_metadata_48 sys_file_metadata_49 sys_file_metadata_50 sys_file_metadata_51 sys_file_metadata_52 sys_file_metadata_53 sys_file_metadata_54 sys_file_metadata_55 sys_file_metadata_57 sys_file_metadata_58 sys_file_metadata_59 sys_file_metadata_60 sys_file_metadata_61 sys_file_metadata_62 sys_file_metadata_63 sys_file_metadata_64 sys_file_metadata_67 sys_file_metadata_68 sys_file_metadata_69 sys_file_metadata_71 sys_file_metadata_72 sys_file_metadata_78 sys_file_metadata_82 sys_file_metadata_84 sys_file_metadata_88 sys_file_metadata_89 sys_file_metadata_90 sys_file_metadata_91 tt_content_1 tt_content_10 tt_content_11 tt_content_12 tt_content_13 tt_content_14 tt_content_15 tt_content_16 tt_content_19 tt_content_2 tt_content_20 tt_content_3 tt_content_4 tt_content_9
    )

    so, it is impossible to develop bigger websites in debug mode?? that is incomprehensible to me ..

  9. Sascha Nowak commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2025-09-23T12:27:56+00:00" > 09/23/25, 12:27 </span>

    @Martin Weymayer thanks for sharing more details. As far as I see the current implementation is working as intended as that configured header limit is 8kb an the header is around 3kb.

    Can you please add a little more details about your development environment.
    • What OS are you using?
    • What webserver are you using and what’s the configured header limit?
    • Are you using default setting or have you changed anything related to the webserver settings?

    Thanks for your support
    Sascha

  10. Martin Weymayer commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2025-09-30T10:57:59+00:00" > 09/30/25, 10:57 </span>

    [X-TYPO3-Cache-Tags] = are not the only tags sent header. printing all were a some more …
    This is shared hosting, I think apache and nginx and plesk using for config panel. header limit is 8kb. I use default settings.

  11. Martin Weymayer commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2025-09-30T10:59:13+00:00" > 09/30/25, 10:59 </span>

    I had also problem on other hosting (also using plesk). The hoster set limit to 32kb I think and then it worked

  12. Garvin Hicking commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2025-09-30T17:12:14+00:00" > 09/30/25, 17:12 </span>

    Could you please patch the MAX_CACHE_TAGS_HEADER_LENGTH = 8000; variable in the PHP file of the patch to this issue and try to set it to 6000 for example? I wonder if maybe the “prefix“ (“x-typo3….”) is factored into the limit?