Issue Feature Rejected

#31303Insert Records: Ability to override header of source record

Urs Braem 10/26/11, 09:49 updated 02/20/25, 07:13

Description

When inserting a record, it will pick up the header from the original article.

That doesn’t fit the needs in many cases, as the context for the inserted article is a different one, and a modification in the header may be needed for clarification.

The original header should be overridden by the Field currently labelled as “name” (if not empty).

An example:

Page 1:

London branch


Our partners


McKenzie
McBuffet Page 2:

Berlin branch


Our partners


Hermann & Söhne
August & Co Page 3:

Our global partners


Our partners


McKenzie
McBuffet

Our partners


Hermann & Söhne
August & Co

-> The h2s on Page 3 should be overrideable with a custom text to state the context:

Page 3:

Our global partners


London


McKenzie
McBuffet

Berlin


Hermann & Söhne
August & Co

One client of mine has for years been structuring his content in an odd way to escape this: he splits an article into a header and a content part, so he can later on reference only the content and place a different header before. Which leads to 3 content elements and a shortcut instead of 1 and a shortcut.

Reviews 0

No change resolves or names this issue in its commit message, and no comment links one.

History 12

  1. Mathias Schreiber changed status New Accepted target version 01/07/15, 17:18

  2. Urs Braem commented 01/07/15, 18:11

    If this would be done 1:1 as I suggested it back then, it would be a very breaking change, I realize.
    The “name” field shouldn’t be used, rather an additional title field that comes into play when used. That would be quite nice.

  3. Benni Mack changed target version 06/15/15, 17:44

  4. Susanne Moog changed target version 08/05/15, 10:31

  5. Benni Mack changed target version 09/24/15, 20:33

  6. Riccardo De Contardi changed target version 02/23/17, 14:55

  7. Susanne Moog changed category 10/27/17, 13:09

  8. Susanne Moog changed target version 01/28/18, 17:44

  9. Susanne Moog changed Sprint Focus On Location Sprint 08/05/22, 13:21

  10. Oliver Hader changed Sprint Focus On Location Sprint 11/03/22, 09:04

  11. Benni Mack commented and changed status Accepted Rejected 02/19/25, 16:41

    Hey Urs,

    I am now closing this issue. To be honest: I understood the idea, but this seems very edge-casy and – in the past 10 years – nobody stepped up to pick this job. This – to me – seems to be a custom Content Type in an extension building such a logic with the headlines… this way, it can be put on extensions.typo3.org, and can be maintained separately.

    I hope that’s OK for you. Sorry that it took so long to get a proper answer from me! Very sorry about this!

    All the best,
    Benni.

  12. Urs Braem commented 02/20/25, 07:13

    Hey Benni
    of course, makes sense. This is outdated.
    Best and thanks for the work!
    Urs