#78426Page settings > Use as Container in wrong tab?
Description
This is micro-minor, but I keep tripping over it.
In the page settings (TYPO3 7), the “use as container; contains plugin” box is in the “behaviour” tab.
I use this to assign a different icon to a folder in the pagetree – nothing else.
Is it correct that it the setting doesn’t do anything else than change the icon?
Because, if yes, then it should rather go to the “Appearance” tab
Reviews 0
No change resolves or names this issue in its commit message, and no comment links one.
Files 3
History 17
-
Mathias Brodala commented and changed status
NewNeeds Feedback 10/25/16, 15:57 -
Urs Braem commented 10/26/16, 14:25
According to Mathias on Slack; probably only for legacy extensions like tt_news, so I’d say this could be moved if it’s of interest
-
Riccardo De Contardi commented 01/06/17, 16:10
Not only for legacy extensions: even if you don’t install any extensions, the dropdown “Contains Plugin” still contains “website users”.
It is inside the “behavior” tab also on 8.6-dev (latest master)
-
Alexander Opitz commented and changed target version 04/28/17, 12:35
IMHO this only changes the Icon of a folder.
Maybe we can do following:
- Moving to appearance and change naming
- Provide a nicer API for the Icon
- Provide some more default Icons?
- Also allow this on “Non Folder” Pages?
Maybe a first example implementation as extension.
Sounds this fine?
-
Urs Braem commented 04/30/17, 20:38
To me: yes, thanks!
> Also allow this on “Non Folder” Pages?
That would be coloring then, as icons come from cTypes already?
Maybe colors would be sufficient, anyway. -
Riccardo De Contardi commented 04/30/17, 22:44
Would you agree if I change the tracker of this issue to “Feature”?
-
Urs Braem commented and changed tracker
BugFeature 05/01/17, 13:45Of course, you are right. I tend to see UX-“Bugs” sometimes…
-
Riccardo De Contardi changed status
Needs FeedbackNew 05/01/17, 16:53 -
Alexander Opitz commented and changed attached Screenshot_20170503_filled_cleaned.png attached Screenshot_20170503_outline_cleaned.png 05/03/17, 12:16
Example with 2 icon designs taken from the KDE Breeze Icon Theme https://github.com/KDE/breeze-icons
-
Urs Braem commented 05/04/17, 13:09
nice!
-
Benni Mack commented 05/05/17, 07:14
This setting can be used for more than just icons, and I believe this was the original intent, giving it some kind of “subtype” (as we have for tt_content as well).
Example: I have quite some projects that only allow to put in certain records into a storage folder:
- Adding a option called “Projects” to the dropdown
- Do a pageTS condition [page|module = projects] to only allow project records (allowedTables) in that folder. Same goes for fields that should be displayed or not displayed.
-
Urs Braem commented 05/05/17, 08:45
Interesting! That’s always an issue with custom extensions. Would you be willing to post the complete setup, how you add the option and restrict the table based on the condition?
-
Alexander Opitz commented 05/08/17, 11:40
@Benni
But this functionality is more ore less independent of the move to “Appearance” tab? And maybe rename it from “Contains Plugin” into something which can follow the behavior.
Also adding colored folders/pages icons shouldn’t change this behavior … it extends this IMHO more. -
Riccardo De Contardi commented 10/07/17, 11:18
Update. In version 8.7, The “Use as container – Contains plugin” is in “Behaviour” tab.
-
Urs Braem commented 10/08/17, 17:42
thank you for the update!
-
Riccardo De Contardi commented 11/03/18, 11:04
There has been no advance on this topic since a lot of time; I write here my considerations:
- on version 9.5.2-dev (latest master) the “Use as container – Contains plugin” is in “Behaviour” tab
- the CSH for the field (the full version) reads"[...] The Frontend display is largely not affected.[...]"
I think that the “Appearance” tab contains settings that instead mostly affects the frontend display (apart from Backend Layout stuff) while in the “behavior” tab there is more a “mixed” situation with some settings that are BE-related and some that are FE-related.
-
Christian Kuhn commented and changed status
NewClosed 02/02/23, 00:18Hey.
The location of the ‘module’ column is currently below ‘behaviour’ and that’s kinda not completely wrong, following the reasons from benni and riccardo.
I hope it’s ok to close here for the time being since this is also open for such a long time already and nobody really fought on something in this area.
Since this is not really a bug/missing feature, please first join us on the TYPO3 Slack to ask your question.