Issue Bug Closed

#87851Copy of localized object has wrong l18n_parent

König David 03/06/19, 17:29 updated 02/19/22, 13:34

Description

If you copy a translated element and paste it in to the same or another site, the field l18n_parent (or in extensions l10n_parent) is filled with the value of the original object (before_paste.png).

So the new copy is not shown in the backend (after_paste.png). This means that it can’t be deleted by an editor.
The copy exists only in the database (database_lookup.png).

In TYPO3 8 and lower you the option mod.web_list.enableLocalizationView can be set, which prevents the user from copying localized records.
Unfortunately, this option has been removed/does not work in TYPO3 9LTS.

Reviews 0

No change resolves or names this issue in its commit message, and no comment links one.

Files 3

History 4

  1. Susanne Moog changed category 03/11/19, 21:19

  2. Riccardo De Contardi commented 04/06/20, 12:05

    Still reproducible with 10.4.0-dev (latest master)

  3. Riccardo De Contardi commented and changed status New Needs Feedback 04/10/21, 21:30

    I think that this issue has been solved;

    I tried the following test with both 10.4.14 and 11.2.0-dev (latest master)

    Prerequisites

    - TYPO3 with two languages defined: Italian(0) and English (1)
    - A page “ test 1 “ in both languages
    - A page “ Test 2 “ in both languages
    - Install Tool > Settings > Configuration Presets > Debug settings: Debug

    Test procedure

    1) Page “ test 1 “ > Page view > language: Italian > create a new content element AAAAA (ID=17)
    2) Translate it (Connected mode) > [Translate to English:] AAAAA (ID=18)
    2.1) If you edit the [Translate to English:] AAAAA (ID=18) record > Tab language > you will see that Transl.Orig[l18n_parent] is “AAAAA [ID=17]”

    3) Page “ test 1 “ > list view > on the AAAAA record, press the “Copy” button
    4) Go to page Test 2 > list view > press the “Paste” button on the top bar

    Results

    1) The “Page content” table is filled with two new records:

    • AAAAA (ID=19)
    • [Translate to English:] AAAAA (ID=20)

    2) the record AAAAA (ID=19) is in italian
    3) the record [Translate to English:] AAAAA (ID=20) is in english, _and its parent is AAAAA (ID=19)!_
    3.1) If you edit the [Translate to English:] AAAAA (ID=20) record > Tab language > you will see that Transl.Orig[l18n_parent] is “AAAAA [ID=19]”

    Is this test sufficient? A different test should be performed? Am I missing something?

  4. Christian Kuhn commented and changed status Needs Feedback Closed 02/19/22, 13:34

    hey. it seems as if this has been resolved meanwhile. i’ll take the freedom to close the issue for now. if the problem still exists, let’s start with a fresh issue.