#90948Object translation broken if object outside Site Configuration
Description
When Objects are placed outside a Site Configuration (root tree of site), translation fails to work. This was not an issue TYPO3 9.
It is common to share translatable objects between different site configurations. It seems to be related to the selection of sys_languages. Inside a site-tree all available languages are available. Outside a site-tree only the main language is availble. Hence, no translation.
Screenshots
Image 1: my site configuration
Image 2: website languages (global)
Image 3a and b: outside site tree (not working)
!image3a.jpg!
image3b.jpg
Image 4a and b: inside site tree (working)
!image4.jpg!
image4b.jpg
Reviews 0
No change resolves or names this issue in its commit message, and no comment links one.
Files 6
History 7
-
Josef Glatz commented and changed description 04/05/20, 11:19
-
Frank Buijze commented 04/07/20, 18:01
Translation does not work on objects outside site-tree. The system does not recognize any language other than default. Languages are not loaded from database within TCA select, nor site configuration. No issues in TYPO3 9.* with this translation of objects outside site tree.
Image 3a en b show that the translation fails. Do I move the object within a site tree, image 4, everthing works. But this is far from logical if you want to use objects accross to site trees.
-
Benni Mack changed target version 04/21/20, 10:41
-
Benni Mack changed target version 04/22/20, 09:44
-
Daniel Haupt commented 07/15/21, 13:07
- seems to be related.
-
Tymoteusz Motylewski changed removed the assignee 07/08/24, 17:55
-
Garvin Hicking commented and changed status
NewClosed 07/09/24, 18:25I’ve consulted with our team and I think as with https://forge.typo3.org/issues/93989 it’s unlikely this will be changed.
The reason is that site configs are more and more bound to their root, and are not really meant to access pages from outside the tree, especially when languages are involved. In the future this will probably even more self-contained.
I will close this issue because of that and hope you can understand.
Improve initial description of issue._