#94566404 page handling is not SEO optimized
Description
Hello,
i think this I celebrate my 15th year working with TYPO3. And still TYPO3 has no good 404 handling.
Current problem appearing on v9.
Let’s say we have a site configuration:
site-1 -> base: http://my.url/site-1
site-2 -> base: http://my.url/site-2
Going to http://my.url/site-1/some-not-existing-page leads to a 404 (correct)
Going to http://my.url/site-2/some-not-existing-page leads to a 404 (correct)
Going to ttp://my.url/some-not-existing-page leads to a redircet to site-1 (not-correct)
[ADD_DESCRIPTION_OF_MIDDLEWARE_STACK_PROBLEM_AND_ADD_SOLUTION_PROPOSEL]
I can already guess that some will argument that this is a SEO related issue that is not the responsibility of TYPO3 core. Well if you think so…
Kind regards
Rozbeh
Reviews 0
No change resolves or names this issue in its commit message, and no comment links one.
History 6
-
Rozbeh Chiryai Sharahi changed description 07/16/21, 10:18
-
Benni Mack changed is private 10/13/21, 14:54
-
Benni Mack commented and changed status
NewNeeds Feedback 11/03/22, 11:36 -
Rozbeh Chiryai Sharahi commented 11/03/22, 18:36
Hello Benni Mack,
I don’t remember “situation” back then anymore, but looking at the description I’d say, that from SEO point of view a 30x redirect of every URL which can not be resolved to a site is not correct.
In the given example this is all a redirect:
http://my.url/a -> 30x
http://my.url/b -> 30x
http://my.url/c -> 30x
http://my.url/d -> 30x
http://my.url/f -> 30xPossible solution imho:
- Introduce a SiteNotFoundErrorHandler
- Dispatch a site-not-found-event, so it can be handled (and document it)…
Possible last fallback: Take the 404 handling of the first existing site.
This could be done on middleware if not already the case in current TYPO3 versions.
Kind regards
Rozbeh Chiryai Sharahi -
Rozbeh Chiryai Sharahi commented 08/05/24, 17:14
@benni In my opinion, this is already solved on version 13.
Following I did:
- Create a `site-1` with root-page-path `/site-1`
- Create a 404 handling for that site
- Navigate to `/site-1/does-not-exists` -> 404 handling of site triggered correctly
- Navigate to `/does-not-exist` -> generic 404 page of typo3 appeared.
=> Perfect and ticket can be closed to my taste.
-
Georg Ringer commented and changed status
Needs FeedbackClosed 08/05/24, 19:14closing as requested
Hey Rozbeh Chiryai Sharahi,
thank you for your report.
Since http://my.url/ has no site configuration, where do you expect to configure a fallback error handler then or how to solve this issue? If you feel that after 15 years, TYPO3 still has no good 404 handling, I would really like to know what can be improved in your situation.
All the best,
Benni.