Issue Bug Closed

#98463Nu HTML Validator (the one from validator.w3.org) changed how they validate self-closing tags

Lars Peter Søndergaard 09/28/22, 13:07 updated 04/03/25, 20:42

Description

This seems to have been a very recent change, and it causes the validator at validator.w3.org now to warn about a lot of self-closing tags, that should no longer be self-closing.

https://github.com/validator/validator/issues/1430

Mostly affected are instances of <img>, <br>, <link> and <meta>

The canonical <link> ag generated by EXT:seo seems to add />, and all tags added by the TYPO3 MetaTag generators seem to add /> as well, and I couldn’t find a way to prevent that, without having to xclass or similar unpretty solutions.

The TagBuilder, used by e.g. the <f:image> ViewHelper also adds /> on self-closing tags.. which is probably a bit harder to solve, as the TagBuilder could potentially represent any tag.

<br /> tags, output by the RTE are also affected. Not sure if it’s possible to prevent that here with some parseFunc setting.

Greetings

Reviews 1

History 9

  1. Lars Peter Søndergaard commented 09/28/22, 13:09

    Lars Peter Søndergaard wrote:
    > This seems to have been a very recent change, and it causes the validator at validator.w3.org now to warn about a lot of self-closing tags, that should no longer be self-closing.

    (How do I edit)
    This was bad wording on my part. Should be: “warn about a lot of self-closing tags with trailing />, that no longer should have that trailing /”

  2. Chris Müller changed Related to #99497 01/09/23, 15:53

  3. Rémy DANIEL commented 01/26/23, 09:56

    The rendering of tags should depends on if the document is a xml document and on the html doctype.

    Some enhancements have been done recently: see https://github.com/TYPO3/typo3/blob/569724111c8d04b9fca2119f1c454e0ac17021d4/typo3/sysext/core/Classes/Type/DocType.php#L114 and its usage.

    But the TagBuilder still needs to adapt: https://github.com/TYPO3/Fluid/blob/c4c625884f6486afd8fb0ae7fc190b14051dc40c/src/Core/ViewHelper/TagBuilder.php#L255

  4. Oliver Schröder commented 04/08/23, 12:09

    The Fluid view helper format.nl2br should be updated too. It uses the PHP function nl2br() which renders
    by default.

  5. Heinz Schilling commented and changed TYPO3 Version 11 12 05/27/24, 11:30

    Still reproducable in 12.4.15

  6. Lars Peter Søndergaard commented 04/01/25, 08:56

    This issue might still be a nice-to-have feature, but I wanted to point out, that the validator has change the level from “Warning” to “Info” (quite some time ago actually)

    https://github.com/validator/validator/issues/1433#issuecomment-1269507818

    So the issue could be closed, but It would still be great if there was a fix in the future to disable trailing slashes on void elements.

    Greetings
    LPS

  7. Garvin Hicking changed Related to #105787 04/03/25, 20:41

  8. Garvin Hicking commented and changed status New Closed 04/03/25, 20:42

    I think this should be done with https://review.typo3.org/c/Packages/TYPO3.CMS/+/87394

    If I mixed something up please let me know and I’ll reopen.