Issue Bug Closed

#107757Different functionality of filter input fields

Christian Rath-Ulrich 10/17/25, 11:01 updated 11/17/26, 21:15

Description

*Problem description*
There are input fields for filtering displayed values in several places in the system, for example:

  • in the search modal [1] (called up via the search icon in the toolbar) and
  • in the “Available objects” [2] area in the ‘Access’ tab of the “Edit page content” interface.

All filter fields are preceded by a gray button with an identical filter icon. However, this icon is not interactive in all cases. This results in inconsistent behavior: despite identical design, the functions differ, which is unpredictable and difficult for users to understand.

*Recommended action*
The functionality and interactivity of the filter icons must be implemented consistently. Either all icons must be interactive and perform the same function, or—if they are purely decorative—they must not be designed in such a way that they can be recognized as control elements.

Uniform implementation is necessary to meet user expectations and ensure consistent operating logic.

  • Search modal filter*
    Bildschirmfoto%202025-10-06%20um%2015.25.53.png
  • Available objects*
    Bildschirmfoto%202025-10-06%20um%2015.26.21.png

Internal reference: 5800

Reviews 1

Files 2

History 3

  1. Oliver Bartsch commented and changed status New Closed <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2026-11-17T21:15:21+00:00" > 11/17/26, 21:15 </span>

    Hey,

    thanks for the detailed report. You’re right about v13: in the live search the filter icon is a real button that opens the “Search in” options, but in the “Available objects” filter of the selectMultipleSideBySide field (e.g. fe_group on the Access tab) the same icon was only decoration.

    This has been changed for TYPO3 v14 with “[TASK] Streamline search field appearance” (#108592, https://review.typo3.org/c/Packages/TYPO3.CMS/+/92145):

    • The decorative filter box in front of the multiselect filter is gone. It is now a plain search field with an inline search icon and the native clear button. It also has a “Filter items” placeholder and aria-label (#109150).
    • In the live search, the filter button now sits after the input and shows a dropdown caret, so it reads clearly as a menu toggle.

    Filter icons that look like controls are now always actual controls. The change was a larger rework of all backend search fields and isn’t suitable for a backport to 13.4, so I’m closing this as resolved in v14. If something still looks inconsistent in v14, please open a new issue with a screenshot.

    Cheers, Oli