Issue Bug Closed

#109327107047 Does not have a deprecation phase

Daniel Siepmann 03/23/26, 14:50 updated 11/17/26, 21:17

Description

The breaking change #107047 got introduced without a deprecation phase.
This leads to extension authors, supporting all active LTS, needing to implement workarounds, e.g. an Event Listener for AfterTcaCompilationEvent to adjust TCA based on active TYPO3 version.

I’d expect the new syntax as a feature, combined with a deprecation of old syntax.
Followed by removal of support of old syntax in TYPO3 v15.0.

Reviews 0

No change resolves or names this issue in its commit message, and no comment links one.

Files 1

History 4

  1. Daniel Siepmann commented and changed attached AfterTcaCompilationEventListener.php <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2026-03-23T14:52:05+00:00" > 03/23/26, 14:52 </span>

    I’ve attached our (not very robust) example implementation of event listener.
    Feel free to use it as inspiration in case there will be no change, and it might keep breaking.

  2. Oliver Bartsch commented and changed status New Closed <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2026-11-17T21:17:48+00:00" > 11/17/26, 21:17 </span>

    Hey,

    thanks for the report and for sharing your listener.

    Removing ds_pointerField in v14.0 was a deliberate [!!!] change. It is documented in the Breaking changelog for #107047, and Core allows such changes in a major release. Most pointer field setups were based on list_type, which was already deprecated in v13 (#105076) and removed in v14. So I’m closing this issue, since for extensions that support v13 and v14, there are actually two options available:

    • tt_content plugins: keep calling ExtensionManagementUtility::addPiFlexFormValue('', 'FILE:EXT:...', 'myext_pi1'). It works in v13 and was kept in v14 as a deprecated method that writes types.<CType>.columnsOverrides.pi_flexform.config.ds. It was only removed in v15. When you drop v13, switch to the new $flexForm argument of addPlugin() / registerPlugin().
    • Custom tables with their own pointer field: v13 needs an array in ds, v14 needs a string. A Typo3Version check in Configuration/TCA/Overrides/*.php is enough for this; you don’t need an AfterTcaCompilationEvent listener.

    If your setup doesn’t fit either case, please add a short TCA example and I’ll look at it again. Thank you!

    All the best, Oli