Issue Bug Closed

#20610HMENU does not show top Level Page in TYPO3 v4.3alpha3

David Bruchmann 06/12/09, 07:25 updated 10/02/18, 12:25

Description

Having a simple HMENU like this:

page.10 = HMENU
page.10 {
1 = TMENU
1.wrap =
|

1.expAll = 1
1.NO.allWrap = |

2 = TMENU
2.NO.allWrap =
|

}

and a page-structure like this:

root (id=1)
Home (id=2)
Blog-Example (id=3)

page root ( id 1 ) is ignored and only shown when it’s called explicitely with another menu-option:

special = directory
special.value = 0

else it’s never shown up.

(issue imported from #M11319)

Reviews 0

No change resolves or names this issue in its commit message, and no comment links one.

History 4

  1. Susanne Moog commented 06/14/09, 18:37

    That’s quite normal behavior afaik. 4.2 doesn’t behave differently (at least not for me)

  2. David Bruchmann commented 06/15/09, 10:43

    That’s right – never remarked that before.
    Nevertheless at least special:rootline and special:directory list the first page.
    I think behavior is not consistent and has to be at least the same.
    For the Bug I described the documentation doesn’t say anything about that and the option entryLevel still has the parameter 0 which is useless.
    So the behavior seems to be a bug in my eyes even it concerns several versions.

    If it’s no bug then documentation and special menus and parameters have to be changed.

  3. Steffen Kamper commented 10/14/09, 20:20

    absolotely correct: this worked never before in any version.
    Reason: there is at least a pidInList used which contains the pids for the rootline. The rootline, and the root template, never resist in pid=0. So you never get the pages that are in pid=0.

    I think this is one of TYPO3 basic which leads to standard page tree constructs: start with a page contain a shortcut to one subpage.

    Finally i see no need to change that behaviour.

  4. Benni Mack changed status Resolved Closed 10/02/18, 12:25