Issue Bug Closed

#81596Resizing animated gif

Naberd Zendi 06/16/17, 13:36 updated 01/05/21, 14:32

Description

when we uploading animated images in DCE
<f:image src="animated gif"></f:image> it shows animation

<f:image src="animated gif" width="100c" height="100c"></f:image> gives us resized image but it’s without animation.

so it seem any resizing of animated gif gives us a static file

guess it misses -coalesce flag while resizing

Reviews 0

No change resolves or names this issue in its commit message, and no comment links one.

History 7

  1. Mona Muzaffar commented and changed category status New Needs Feedback 06/19/17, 09:59

    I am not too sure if it is or was possible to resize gifs with fluid.
    Once you resize it, the gif gets saved as a newly scaled image in the ‘_processed’ folder and thus looses it’s animation.

    So imho this is more of a feature request than a bug.

  2. Naberd Zendi commented 07/07/17, 14:32

    Mona Muzaffar wrote:
    > I am not too sure if it is or was possible to resize gifs with fluid.
    > Once you resize it, the gif gets saved as a newly scaled image in the ‘_processed’ folder and thus looses it’s animation.
    >
    > So imho this is more of a feature request than a bug.

    not sure if it uses gd lib or similar to resize then it just needs flag. otherwise it is indeed a request to a future.

  3. Riccardo De Contardi commented 07/08/17, 18:19

    as far as I know it is always difficult to resize an animated gif, you could end up with an heavier file or visual artifacts (see a little discussion here: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/12293832/problems-when-resizing-cinemagraphs-animated-gifs )

  4. Susanne Moog changed category 10/26/17, 15:50

  5. Riccardo De Contardi changed Related to #51049 10/27/17, 17:21

  6. Alexander Opitz commented and changed status Needs Feedback Closed 03/09/18, 11:26

    Resizing of animations can’t be handled correctly by IM/GM as it is problematic by design.

    So I’m closing this issue, as we can’t do much here.

  7. Gabriel Kaufmann TYPOworx GmbH | NewMedia commented 01/05/21, 14:32

    I know there are most times lot better options than animated Gif’s, but sometimes one can’t get rid of them either by time or customer-budget.

    I found a solution in optimizing animated gif’s on linux CLI and so far I’ve read the article Imagick should be able to do it (now in the meantime?) as well:

    https://superuser.com/questions/1107200/optimize-animated-gif-size-in-command-line

    This works like a charm reducing a horrible 4 megabyte Gif animation to only a fraction of the original-size (output-size was 1.6M in my case by combining resize & optimize).

    $> gifsicle -i anim.gif --optimize=3 --resize 400x400 -o anim-opt.gif