Issue Bug Closed

#97803User has no page mount but gets the whole page tree

Bernhard Eckl 06/22/22, 08:32 updated 10/06/26, 17:23

Description

I created a new user and assigned a default group which assigns modules and config settings but no page in the db mounts. When I switch to the user I can see all pages in the pagetree (wrong behaviour, no page should be seen). If I assign the user or its group a page db mount only that page is shown (correct behaviour).

Reviews 0

No change resolves or names this issue in its commit message, and no comment links one.

History 6

  1. Hartmut Steglich commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2022-06-23T13:55:57+00:00" > 06/23/22, 13:55 </span>

    had this recently also in TYPO3 >= 11.5.9

  2. Riccardo De Contardi commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2023-07-29T14:52:16+00:00" > 07/29/23, 14:52 </span>

    I have performed the following test with TYPO3 9, 10, 11, 12, 13:

    Prerequisites

    • fresh TYPO3 installation
    • some pages on the pageTree, a starting home page and a couple of subpages
    • an “editors” BE group
    • an “editor” BE user

    Test procedure

    1. Access module > ensure that all the pages belong to the “Editors” group (owner can be your admin user)
    2. [Root] > list view > edit “editors” BE Group and
    2.1 Tab “Access List” > add everything
    2.2 Tab “Mounts and Workspaces” > DO NOT ADD a DB Mount
    2.3 Save & close

    3. [Root] > list view > edit “editor” BE User and
    3.1 Tab “Access List” > add everything
    3.2 Tab “Mounts and Workspaces” > DO NOT ADD a DB Mount and check “Mount from groups” > DB Mount
    3.3 Save & Close

    • Switch to “Editor”
    • Click on page module Page module

    Test Results

    TYPO3 Version Pagetree Interaction with the pagetree (i.e. clicking on a page)
    9.5.31 the pagetree is totally absent no interaction is possible, an error card is shown on the right side of the interface with the text “Page tree error
    Got unexpected response from the server. Please check logs for details.”
    10.4.37 the pagetree is visible and shows the pages belonging to the group The backend crashes with the error message:
    Whoops, looks like something went wrong.
    (1/1) #1289917924 RuntimeException
    You don’t have access to this page
    in /Sites/typo3.10.test.composer.it/public/typo3/sysext/backend/Classes/Http/RouteDispatcher.php line 157
    11.5.30 the pagetree is visible and shows the pages belonging to the group it shows an error page with the message:
    *503*
    Oops, an error occurred!
    You don’t have access to this page
    12.4.4 and 13.0.0-dev the pagetree is visible and shows the pages belonging to the group The backend crashes with the error message:
    Whoops, looks like something went wrong.
    (1/1) #1289917924 RuntimeException
    You don’t have access to this page
    in /var/www/html/vendor/typo3/cms-backend/Classes/Middleware/BackendModuleValidator.php line 184
  3. Riccardo De Contardi commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2024-06-17T07:05:51+00:00" > 06/17/24, 07:05 </span>

    I write here the description of #101336 (“Pages are shown in page tree even if (non-admin) BE user has no DB mounts and “Mount from groups” “DB Mounts” is off”) to keep track of it

    > This could also be a privacy problem because user sees pages in page tree which he has no business seeing (which might be access protected).
    >
    > He can also sees
    > – which user is currently editing the page (see first screenshot)
    >
    > I could reproduce it in a way where the user sees all pages in entire installation (even though they are not even in the DB mount in the group).
    >
    > Is only reproducable
    >
    > – if the user does not have any DB mounts at all
    > – OR has a DB mount but no permission for the pages.
    >
    > This could happen by wrong page permissions or misconfiguration of BE user.
    >
    > Reproduce
    > create user with no DB mount and set “Mount from groups” | “DB mounts” to off, assign this user to a group
    > add a DB mount in the group
    > switch to user
    > switch to page module (or list module)
    > Result
    > The pages which are available for the group will now be displayed in the pagetree but the user has no access to them. If he clicks on a page, exception is thrown: “You don’t have access to this page”.
    >
    > Also: context menu | “Info” is displayed, but this results in error message: “Sorry, you didn’t have proper permissions to perform this change.“
    >
    > Expected behaviour
    > – If the user does not have access to the pages, they should not be displayed in the page tree and if he has access to no pages, no pages should be displayed in page tree
    > – in one case, an exception is thrown, in the other (Context “Info”) a modal dialog is displayed with error. I would always expect the error message, not the exception
    >
    > Setupuser1:
    > has mostly default permissions, no DB mounts or any modifications of permissions, except:
    > has group group1
    > “Mounts and Workspaces” | ““Mount from groups” | “DB Mounts” is off
    > group1
    > has DB mount (page id 1)
    > has access to all modules: “Access Lists” | “Modules” : all selected
    > has (read) access to all tables: “Access Lists” | “Tables (listing)” : all selected
    > page tree (page id 1):
    > “everybody” has all permisions (set in “Access” module)
    > Versions
    > Reproduced with
    >
    > v11 … latest main

  4. Georg Ringer commented and changed status New Closed <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2026-10-06T17:23:43+00:00" > 10/06/26, 17:23 </span>

    fixed with #104397