Issue Feature Rejected

#98227Form definition import/export

Katharina Strasser 08/30/22, 09:34 updated 06/20/24, 07:00

Description

Typo3 does allow the download of .form.yaml files from the form_definitions folder via the file list, but not their upload.

Therefore, an editor cannot copy a complex form to another site without having access to the file system via ssh/ftp.

This is why I suggest an import/export feature for the forms. This would allow editors easily to copy forms between multiple sites.

Reviews 0

No change resolves or names this issue in its commit message, and no comment links one.

History 3

  1. Oliver Hader commented 08/30/22, 10:14

    The reason of denying uploads of form definitions (.form.yaml) by regular editors is due to https://typo3.org/security/advisory/typo3-core-sa-2018-003 – especially form finishers allowed to execute arbitrary changes.

    Assuming the form parts of a form definition is safe, it might be possible to upload/adjust .form.yaml files directly, in case they don’t define any finisher processing.

  2. Oliver Hader changed subject From import/export Form definition import/export 08/31/22, 21:42

  3. Georg Ringer commented and changed status New Rejected 06/20/24, 07:00

    Hey Katharina,

    thanks for the issue. Editors should really not work with those YAML files as one space character can break the form. If the editors you are working with can handle that, feel free to xclass/patch and remove the code to deny yml files but be aware of the additional security issue.

    the core won’t provide an upload feature