Issue Bug Closed

#103582SiteConfiguration: Empty fallback not working anymore

Mark Weisgerber 04/09/24, 19:01 updated 11/13/26, 13:37

Description

Hi,
Since the latest update to V12.4.14, the “fallbacks” field from the SiteConfiguration for languages no longer seems to work.
Previously I had the following configuration in my languages:

languages:
  - languageId: 0
    enabled: true
    title: Deutsch
    base: 'https://www.darf-ich-mit.de/'
    locale: de_DE.utf8
    navigationTitle: Deutsch
    hreflang: de-DE
    direction: ''
    flag: de
    websiteTitle: ''
    deeplTargetLanguage: DE
  - languageId: 1
    enabled: true
    title: Polnisch
    base: 'https://www.fellow.dog/pl/'
    locale: pl_PL.utf8
    navigationTitle: Polski
    hreflang: pl-PL
    direction: ''
    fallbackType: strict
    fallbacks: ''
    flag: pl
    websiteTitle: ''
    deeplTargetLanguage: PL
  - languageId: 2
    enabled: true
    title: Englisch
    websiteTitle: fellow.dog
    base: 'https://www.fellow.dog/'
    locale: en_US.utf8
    navigationTitle: English
    hreflang: en-US
    direction: ''
    fallbackType: strict
    fallbacks: ''
    flag: en-us-gb
    deeplTargetLanguage: EN-US

The MainLanguage works, but all other languages only render an empty content area.
The remedy is to define “fallbacks: ‘0’” everywhere, but this is a behavior I don’t want because I only want to display data records for which a translation exists

I reverted the update back to 12.4.13 and it works again.

Reviews 2

History 11

  1. Mark Weisgerber commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2024-04-09T19:06:14+00:00" > 04/09/24, 19:06 </span>

    Please remove the asterisks at fallbacks: ‘’, this is actually markup because I wanted to make the text bold. Unfortunately I can’t edit the text.

  2. Stefan Bürk commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2024-04-20T21:51:34+00:00" > 04/20/24, 21:51 </span>

    Mark Weisgerber wrote in #note-1:
    > Please remove the asterisks at fallbacks: ‘’, this is actually markup because I wanted to make the text bold. Unfortunately I can’t edit the text.

    What do you mean ? which asterisks ?

  3. Stefan Bürk commented and changed status New Needs Feedback assigned to Stefan Bürk <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2024-04-20T22:14:15+00:00" > 04/20/24, 22:14 </span>

    Can you provide some more context ? More about a constelation or how to create something, beside the SiteConfiguration and what you get versus what you expect (or got before).

    I tested it with TYPO3 v12 (monorepo) and v13 (monorepo) with following scenario:

    • two languages, default (EN)0 and german (DE)1 in SiteConfiguration, (DE)1 configured with fallbackType: strict and fallbacks: ''
    • created a new page (default langauge) and added two content elements
    • create a translated page (not translating/copy any elements)
    • preview page (DE)1 -> no content elements rendered > expected * translate page content from default language, only selecting one element to translate * preview page (DE)[1] -> only the translated content element is shown > expected
    languages:
      -
        title: English
        enabled: true
        languageId: 0
        base: /
        locale: en_US.UTF-8
        navigationTitle: English
        flag: us
        typo3Language: default
        iso-639-1: en
        hreflang: en-us
        direction: ltr
        websiteTitle: ''
      -
        title: 'styleguide demo language german'
        enabled: true
        base: /de/
        typo3Language: de
        locale: de_DE.UTF-8
        iso-639-1: de
        websiteTitle: ''
        navigationTitle: ''
        hreflang: de-de
        direction: ltr
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: de
        languageId: 1

    Not tested it with 12.4.14 or 12.4.13, only with 12.4.15-dev

    I’d say that is the expected behaviour – at least from my understanding. If you get default
    content elements on a translated page without any element with 12.4.13 and fallbackType: strict
    and fallbacks: '' that’s most likely a BUG which has been fixed (intendet or not intendet).

    Did not searched deeply for a fix, but scrolling through the release notes for 12.4.14 I cannot
    identify which change may have changed that behaviour [1] or being a canditate for it.

    [1] https://get.typo3.org/release-notes/12.4.14

  4. Mark Weisgerber commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2024-04-23T17:40:02+00:00" > 04/23/24, 17:40 </span>

    Sure, I’ll try to go into more detail.

    The project runs in composer mode and uses the latest version of EXT:bootstrap_package. I’ve thought about whether this could have something to do with the extension, but there’s nothing in the Github issue panel so far.

    I have about 20 languages and all of them should behave strictly and only display content if it has been translated. I never want to display a fallback to another language.
    For all languages I use this fallback config (except for languageID 0)

        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''

    Let’s start from the home page: I have a content element in my default language and have translated (not copied) it into any other language.
    In the frontend, the page is displayed correctly, but when I switch to another language, it does not show me any content element, but only the translated layout.

    However, with TYPO3 12.4.13 it works correctly
    In my staging system with TYPO3 12.4.14 the above mentioned behavior occurs. (If required, I can also provide backend access)

    The content elements are rendered in the Bootstrap_Package as follows:
    https://github.com/benjaminkott/bootstrap_package/blob/master/Configuration/TypoScript/ContentElement/Helper/DynamicContent.typoscript

    Use in Fluid:

    <f:cObject typoscriptObjectPath="lib.dynamicContent" data="{pageUid: '{data.uid}', colPos: '0', slide: '{theme.pagelayout.{pagelayout}.colPos.0.slide}'}" />

    Here is the full language-block from the sites.yaml:

    languages:
      - languageId: 0
        enabled: true
        title: Deutsch
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/'
        locale: de_DE.utf8
        navigationTitle: Deutsch
        flag: de
        websiteTitle: ''
        deeplTargetLanguage: DE
      - languageId: 1
        enabled: true
        title: Polnisch
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/pl/'
        locale: pl_PL.utf8
        navigationTitle: Polski
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: pl
        websiteTitle: ''
        deeplTargetLanguage: PL
      - languageId: 2
        enabled: true
        title: Englisch
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/en/'
        locale: en_US.utf8
        navigationTitle: English
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: en-us-gb
        deeplTargetLanguage: EN-US
      - languageId: 3
        title: Niederländisch
        locale: nl_NL.utf8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/nl/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Nederlands
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: nl
        enabled: true
        deeplTargetLanguage: NL
      - languageId: 4
        title: Dänisch
        locale: da_DK.utf8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/da/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Dansk
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: dk
        enabled: true
        deeplTargetLanguage: DA
      - languageId: 5
        title: Italienisch
        locale: it_IT.utf8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/it/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Italiano
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: it
        enabled: true
        deeplTargetLanguage: IT
      - languageId: 6
        title: Tschechisch
        locale: cs_CZ.utf8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/cz/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: čeština
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: cz
        enabled: true
        deeplTargetLanguage: CS
      - languageId: 7
        title: Spanisch
        locale: es_ES.utf8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/es/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Español
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: es
        enabled: true
        deeplTargetLanguage: ES
      - languageId: 8
        title: Französisch
        locale: fr_FR.utf8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/fr/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Français
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: fr
        enabled: true
        deeplTargetLanguage: FR
      - languageId: 9
        title: Schwedisch
        locale: se_SE.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/se/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: svenska
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: se
        enabled: false
        deeplTargetLanguage: SV
      - languageId: 10
        title: Japanisch
        locale: ja_JP.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/jp/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: 日本
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: jp
        enabled: true
        deeplTargetLanguage: JA
      - languageId: 11
        title: Rumänisch
        locale: ro_RO.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/ro/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Română
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: ro
        enabled: false
        deeplTargetLanguage: RO
      - title: Griechisch
        locale: gr_GR.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/gr/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Ελληνικά
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: gr
        enabled: false
        languageId: 12
        deeplTargetLanguage: EL
      - title: Türkisch
        locale: tr_TR.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/tr/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Türkçe
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: tr
        enabled: false
        languageId: 13
        deeplTargetLanguage: TR
      - title: Lettisch
        locale: lv_LV.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/lv/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Latviešu
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: lv
        enabled: false
        languageId: 14
        deeplTargetLanguage: LV
      - title: Ungarisch
        locale: hu_HU.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/hu/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Magyar
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: hu
        enabled: false
        languageId: 15
        deeplTargetLanguage: HU
      - title: Slowenisch
        locale: si_SI.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/si/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Slovenščina
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: si
        enabled: false
        languageId: 16
        deeplTargetLanguage: SL
      - title: Finnisch
        locale: fi_FI.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/fi/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Suomalainen
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: fi
        enabled: false
        languageId: 17
        deeplTargetLanguage: FI
      - title: Bulgarisch
        locale: bg_BG.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/bg/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: български
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: bg
        enabled: false
        languageId: 18
        deeplTargetLanguage: BG
      - title: Litauisch
        locale: bg_BG.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/lt/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: lietuvių
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: lt
        enabled: false
        languageId: 19
        deeplTargetLanguage: LT
      - title: Portugiesisch
        locale: pt_PT.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/pt/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Português
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: pt
        enabled: false
        languageId: 20
        deeplTargetLanguage: PT-PT
      - title: Chinesisch
        locale: cn_CN.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/cn/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: 中文
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: cn
        enabled: false
        languageId: 21
        deeplTargetLanguage: ZH
      - title: Norwegisch
        locale: no_NO.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/no/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: norsk
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: no
        enabled: false
        languageId: 22
        deeplTargetLanguage: NB
      - title: Indonesisch
        locale: id_ID.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/id/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Bahasa Indonesia
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: id
        enabled: false
        languageId: 23
        deeplTargetLanguage: ID
      - title: Koreanisch
        locale: kr_KR.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/kr/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: 한국어
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: kr
        enabled: false
        languageId: 24
        deeplTargetLanguage: KO
      - title: Slowakisch
        locale: sk_SK.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/sk/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Slovenská
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: sk
        enabled: false
        languageId: 25
        deeplTargetLanguage: SK
      - title: Estnisch
        locale: ee_EE.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/ee/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Eesti
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: ee
        enabled: false
        languageId: 26
        deeplTargetLanguage: ET
      - direction: rtl
        title: Arabisch
        locale: ar_SA.UTF-8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/ar/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: العربية
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: sa
        enabled: false
        languageId: 27
        deeplTargetLanguage: AR
      - title: Russisch
        locale: ru_RU.utf8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/ru/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Русский
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: ru
        enabled: false
        languageId: 28
        deeplTargetLanguage: RU
      - languageId: 29
        title: Ukrainisch
        locale: ru_UA.utf8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/ua/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: Українська
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: ua
        enabled: false
        deeplTargetLanguage: UK
      - languageId: 30
        title: Hindi
        locale: hi_IN.utf8
        base: 'https://test.darf-ich-mit.de/hi/'
        websiteTitle: fellow.dog
        navigationTitle: हिन्दी
        fallbackType: strict
        fallbacks: ''
        flag: in
        enabled: false

    Have I forgotten something that might be important? Please let me know if there is anything I can do.
    Maybe it has something to do with the fact that I use German as LanguageID 0?

  5. Mark Weisgerber commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2024-06-11T17:52:48+00:00" > 06/11/24, 17:52 </span>

    Hi,

    i just located the problem. When i undo this commit, it works again:
    https://github.com/TYPO3/typo3/commit/6578a968349ac336dd816d405ddab26b1b299565

    But I don’t know why the menu has an effect on my content rendering. Does anyone have any ideas? Is this even a bug or is the problem with me?

  6. Daniel Siepmann commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2024-07-09T08:52:18+00:00" > 07/09/24, 08:52 </span>

    The menu uses the ContentObjectRenderer.
    This carries state, e.g. of the current page.

    The state is changed for each language/page to generate links for within menus.
    If things go bad, the state is kept.
    The system might then think that it should render a different page or page in a different language.
    That’s what was tried to be solved with the commit you’ve linked.

  7. Benni Mack commented and changed status Needs Feedback Closed <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2026-11-13T13:35:24+00:00" > 11/13/26, 13:35 </span>

    done – you can test it again…

  8. Benni Mack commented <span data-processor="relativetime" data-value="2026-11-13T13:37:57+00:00" > 11/13/26, 13:37 </span>

    Closing this issue as it has been fixed since TYPO3 v12.4.18 and v13.3.0 via #104335 (https://review.typo3.org/c/Packages/TYPO3.CMS/+/85175). If building a menu link failed, for example a language menu linking to an untranslated page with fallbackType: strict, the current page record was not restored. The rest of the page then rendered with the wrong record, which left the content area empty. If you still see this on a current version, please open a new issue with steps to reproduce.